Regulatory Open Forum

 View Only
  • 1.  Addition of drug substance manufacturer for a drug product of different strengths

    Posted 22-Oct-2020 07:13
    Dear Regex (esp. CMC folks),
    What studies should support a variation of "Addition of drug substance manufacturer for a drug product of different strengths"?
    If comparative dissolution is a requirement, would it be enough to be carried out on a batch made from the new source for the highest  strength (BE strength) only? or the study should be made for all the other strengths?
    Providing a reference for the same is highly appreciated either from US or EU regulations/guidances.

    ------------------------------
    Alaa El Kazak Msc., RAC
    Jeddah
    Saudi Arabia
    https://www.linkedin.com/in/alaaelkazak/
    ------------------------------


  • 2.  RE: Addition of drug substance manufacturer for a drug product of different strengths

    This message was posted by a user wishing to remain anonymous
    Posted 23-Oct-2020 16:35
    This message was posted by a user wishing to remain anonymous

    If the formulation is proportional for all different strengths of product, then bracketing approach (highest and lowest) would be justified.


  • 3.  RE: Addition of drug substance manufacturer for a drug product of different strengths

    Posted 24-Oct-2020 10:02
    Could you provide a link of the related guidance?

    ---------------------------------
    Alaa El Kazak Msc., RAC
    Jeddah
    Saudi Arabia
    https://www.linkedin.com/in/alaaelkazak/
    ---------------------------------





  • 4.  RE: Addition of drug substance manufacturer for a drug product of different strengths

    Posted 03-Nov-2020 09:12
    I spoke to one of my colleagues who works with small molecules, and she said that it would be sufficient to test only the worst-case (which you would have to justify). This is supported in the draft FDA guidance "Postapproval Changes to Drug Substances" (https://www.fda.gov/media/115733/download):

    Change in the drug substance source…The manufacture of a batch of drug product using the post-modification drug substance is not always required. However, when, as a result of the change, the drug substance equivalence cannot be established, and the drug substance physical properties can affect manufacturability or performance of the drug product, application holders must assess the drug product made with the post-modification drug substance before distributing the drug product. In such cases a batch of drug product should be manufactured to fully evaluate the effect of a change in drug substance manufacturing. In vitro testing (e.g., dissolution, in vitro release) demonstrating the equivalence of the drug product made from the post-modification drug substance to the drug product made from the pre-modification drug substance

     When the drug product is available in multiple strengths (including different formulations), a batch of only one strength may be manufactured. The strength chosen for evaluation should be the strength most sensitive to changes in the drug substance's physical properties. If there is no evidence of one strength being more sensitive than another, the lowest strength should be used for low-dose drug products; the highest strength should be used for all other products. A scientific rationale for the strength chosen should be provided in the submission to FDA. In the case of complex dosage forms with multiple strengths, such as modified release products, one batch per strength may be needed.

    There are also decision trees on page 15 and 36 of this document that provide further guidance.


    ------------------------------
    Rachel Thornton
    Associate Director
    Smyrna GA
    United States
    ------------------------------



  • 5.  RE: Addition of drug substance manufacturer for a drug product of different strengths

    Posted 05-Nov-2020 06:43
    Thanks alot Rachel for your care and support. Really appreciate it.

    Regards,
    Alaa Elkazak





  • 6.  RE: Addition of drug substance manufacturer for a drug product of different strengths

    Posted 05-Nov-2020 09:00
    Hi Alaa, 

    Please see guidance for  BA/BE requirements along with guidance when you come across a situation such as yours 

    https://www.fda.gov/files/drugs/published/Bioavailability-and-Bioequivalence-Studies-Submitted-in-NDAs-or-INDs-%E2%80%94-General-Considerations.pdf

    ------------------------------
    Sai Prathyusha Bhamidipati
    Associate Director, Regulatory Affairs
    Medford MA
    United States
    ------------------------------