Regulatory Open Forum

 View Only
  • 1.  Communication SOP

    Posted 27-Oct-2023 05:06

    Hi everyone,

    I am wondering if one of you has a template he can share of a SOP related to communication with external parties (authorities, customers) ? Thanks in advance.



    ------------------------------
    Quang Tran
    VP QARA
    Antony
    France
    ------------------------------


  • 2.  RE: Communication SOP

    Posted 27-Oct-2023 09:54

    For the context of ISO 13485:2016 clause 7.2.3 first paragraph requiring that we "plan and document arrangements for" (I view that to be different than "document procedures for") communicating with customers in various ways, and regarding clause 7.2.3 second paragraph requiring that we "communicate with" (I again view that to be different than "document procedures for") regulatory authorities, I have our clients simply use the corresponding section of the Quality Manual to document the organization's corresponding policy promises plus therewith to reference the corresponding documented procedures where such procedures are required elsewhere by ISO 13485 (i.e., the clause 8.2.1 feedback procedure; the clause 8.2.2 complaint handling procedure; the clause 8.3.3 advisory notice procedure; and the clause 8.2.3 procedure for reporting to regulatory authorities).  And for the parts of clause 7.2.3 that don't require us to "document procedures" (i.e., regarding customer communication about product information, enquiries, and contracts or order handling, including amendments, and regarding regulatory authority communication other than reporting, such as regarding periodic facility registration or regarding agency inspections), I have our clients reference their corresponding voluntary documented procedures if they exist or else write a corresponding narrative in the Quality Manual that at least assigns responsibilities and gives a brief explanation of how the organization communicates with customers and regulatory authorities about those topics.  This has always been a successful approach when clients were audited by external auditors.



    ------------------------------
    Kevin Randall, ASQ CQA, RAC (Europe, U.S., Canada)
    Principal Consultant
    Ridgway, CO
    United States
    © Copyright 2023 by ComplianceAcuity, Inc. All rights reserved.
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: Communication SOP

    Posted 30-Oct-2023 05:13

    Thank you Kevin,

    This is not a ISO 13485 but a MDR 2017/745 requirements on art.10 :

    (j) handling communication with competent authorities, notified bodies, other economic operators, customers and/or
    other stakeholders;

    Anyway my question was not how to fullfill with the requirement but if someone has a template or know where to find a template :)

    Thanks in advance,



    ------------------------------
    Quang Tran
    VP QARA
    Antony
    France
    ------------------------------



  • 4.  RE: Communication SOP

    Posted 30-Oct-2023 07:02

    Hello Quang,

    Maybe someone at a company participating in the forums here would have a procedure which could be shared.  Often procedures and templates are considered intellectual property especially to consulting firms, so you might need to engage with one of them to help develop a procedure for your quality system.  Indeed, under Article 10 there is this "communication" requirement with various parties and stakeholders.  And yes, it is asked for and also something we ask for as part of an EU MDR quality system assessment because ... it is asked for by Notified Body auditors.  Typically you could have one over-arching procedure which is "Communicating with Stakeholders" where this procedure could have separate sections addressing the types of communication, who you communicate, what you communicate, and when you communicate.  Depending on how many products/product families there are or the size of the company, this procedure is appropriate (for single products and small companies).

    For larger organisations, we still generate an over-arching communication procedure, but this procedure is an "index" which references than individual procedures related to a stakeholder.  As an example, there is a "Communicating with Notified Bodies" procedure which has various items such as audit planning, Technical Documentation review, notification of changes, notification of serious incidents, notification of FSCA, etc. etc.  This procedure then references the individual quality system procedures where this is managed, e.g. change control or Vigilance procedure.  Just as above, the procedure describes when, who, what, why, and the circumstances around communicating with Notified Bodies.  Then there are individual procedures for the different stakeholders which then provide references to the various procedures managing the processes.  Is this too much?  Probably.  But then so are the expectations auditors and reviewers are demanding under EU MDR.  There is the requirement in Article 10 for handling communications, so this could probably be simply done with a procedure, but really depends on the organisation and all of those interactions outside of the company.



    ------------------------------
    Richard Vincins ASQ-CQA, MTOPRA, RAC
    Vice President Global Regulatory Affairs
    ------------------------------



  • 5.  RE: Communication SOP

    Posted 30-Oct-2023 13:22

    Thank you Richard, I agree with you, I think that I have no other choice that doing it by myself unfortunately.



    ------------------------------
    Quang Tran
    VP QARA
    Antony
    France
    ------------------------------



  • 6.  RE: Communication SOP

    Posted 30-Oct-2023 12:50

    Thank you, Quang for that additional jurisdictional detail.  I believe my first post already lays out a template for how to do this, though one would still need to adapt it into one's own quality management system document format(s).  I explain further below.

    Specifically, since the Union's MDR and IVDR demand that we take into account the generally acknowledged state of the art, and since EN ISO 13485:2016 (as corrected and amended, e.g., via AC:2018 and A11:2021, hereinafter "13485") is a generally acknowledged state of the art standard for the quality management system, then many organizations either a) have a corresponding official certification from their Notified Body (which I understand you do not, and that's okay), or else b) at least design their quality management system in principle to be in accordance with the principles/provisions of 13485 even though the organization doesn't have an actual certification.  Moreover, 13485 is harmonized for the Union MDR which further increases its stock value in the eyes of a Union MDR auditor (whether internal or external).

    Dismissing the state of the art may be appropriate in certain cases.  But generally, it isn't advisable in my opinion due to global harmonization of quality management systems around the basic principles and intent of 13485.

    In either case, 13485's generally acknowledged state of the art doesn't require an actual separate general "procedure" for the aforesaid communication; instead, the minimum requirement is laid out in my first post of this thread.  In the interest of "nimble documentation" and a least burdensome approach to the quality management system, I recommend avoiding too many procedures that might overcomplicate or bloat the quality management system.  I maintain this regardless of NB auditors' possible tendency for reflexively demanding overcomplication or more procedures than what is legislatively required.  If one embraces the spirit of the least burdensome approach, then again, my first post in this thread lays out a template for how to do this regarding communication with external parties; though as mentioned, one would still need to adapt it into one's own quality management system document formats.



    ------------------------------
    Kevin Randall, ASQ CQA, RAC (Europe, U.S., Canada)
    Principal Consultant
    Ridgway, CO
    United States
    © Copyright 2023 by ComplianceAcuity, Inc. All rights reserved.
    ------------------------------