Hi Anon,
First of all, this is not just an American standard. This is published as an international standard by the Standards Development Organization (SDO) ASTM International. While it is not published in the Official Journal (OJ) as a Harmonised standard, it is for international use (just like an ISO or IEC standard). It is time that we all hold the Notified Bodies accountable to simply follow the rules and not allow them to make an interpretation that is NOT valid. A standard not being publish in the OJ (or not on the FDA recognized list) does NOT invalidate that standard. As we have experienced, there are other issues at play here in those processed to get the list published and that gets in the way of the process. We as an industry need to set the rules here and they also need to play by those rules.
1) If there is sufficient information in the regulation, this takes precedence
2) If there is a published list of recognized standards (published in the OJ/FDA list), this is next
3) Other relevant international standards (yes, if published by a country/region specific one, you should use that one for the country you are marketing the product) and guidance--note that country participation in an international SDO often comes with agreements (like the Vienna agreement) that they will not change the normative portions of standards
4) Other industry or country standards
5) sector or company standards--this can often require additional validation
Understand, this can create some conflicts and those may need to be discussed, but we all need to understand the agreements that are behind the SDO and this is why the Notified Body has to register with an Accreditation Body (they are the ones to hold them to the rules).
------------------------------
Regards,
Mark Swanson, ASQ CBA, CMQ/OE, CQE ASQ, MBA
Becker MN
United States
------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 02-Aug-2022 08:36
From: Anonymous Member
Subject: EU MDR and acceptance of ASTM standard
This message was posted by a user wishing to remain anonymous
Hi all,
Does anybody know whether the EU Notified Bodies accept shelf-life testing of non-sterile medical devices compliant with the American ASTM-F1980? It looks like there is no generic European standard published for non-sterile medical devices, and the ASTM seems to be the most appropriate one.
Thank you