Regulatory Open Forum

 View Only
Expand all | Collapse all

QMS sofware and Clinical Study Management software solution for Med Device

  • 1.  QMS sofware and Clinical Study Management software solution for Med Device

    This message was posted by a user wishing to remain anonymous
    Posted 16-Aug-2019 11:42
    This message was posted by a user wishing to remain anonymous

    Hi all,  

    We are planning to get implement QMS software solution and software to manage clinical study data for medical device. 

    Would love to find software that has QMS related modules such as CAPA, Complaint Handling, Audit management, Supplier Management etc and also have option for clinical study data management.  

    Currently, we are planning to reach out to Master Control and Pilgrims.  We would need to have cost effective option for small size company (less than 60 employees). 

    Any input on how to go about find in out potential solutions and implementation is greatly appreciated.

    Thanks you. 




  • 2.  RE: QMS sofware and Clinical Study Management software solution for Med Device

    Posted 16-Aug-2019 14:46
    Master Control is one of a best choice and may be you can check out TrackWise!

    ------------------------------
    Loganathan Kumarasamy, MS RAC
    Senior Consultant
    Waukegan IL
    United States
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: QMS sofware and Clinical Study Management software solution for Med Device

    Posted 17-Aug-2019 09:34
    Check out Grand Avenue. It is a very cost effective solution for small companies and easy to use.  The company is good to work with as well.  I do not know if they have implemented clinical data management into it though or if they have plans to.

    ------------------------------
    Amy McKinney RAC
    Sr Manager, Regulatory Affairs, Interventional Oncology
    Fulshear TX
    United States
    ------------------------------



  • 4.  RE: QMS sofware and Clinical Study Management software solution for Med Device

    Posted 18-Aug-2019 11:07
    We recently implemented the Veeva Vault Quality Docs system as well as the Veeva eTMF after doing extensive research following an internal needs assessment.  This is a cloud based system that is 21CFR11 compliant with a lot of features and benefits, particularly for smaller organizations (as they offer a less expensive off-the-shelf product).  There is rapid implementation and best of all, many of our manufacturing partners are using it (making it much easier during audits).  They upgrade their products regularly and offer a CTMS solution as well as other products that can be purchased for an end-to-end solution.  Veeva has been in business for a number of years and is geared toward the life sciences.

    ------------------------------
    Jennifer Kealy
    Head of Clinical and Regulatory Affairs
    Genève
    Switzerland
    ------------------------------



  • 5.  RE: QMS sofware and Clinical Study Management software solution for Med Device

    Posted 19-Aug-2019 03:06
    Whatever the claim by a vendor, they cannot under any circumstances sell 21 CFR Part 11 compliant software 
    They can sell software that can principally be operated in a compliant manner 
    The user must demonstrate compliance

    Please don't be fooled by mischievous claims about Part 11 compliance 

    Regards 
    Siegfried 

    Vice President Technical 





  • 6.  RE: QMS sofware and Clinical Study Management software solution for Med Device

    Posted 22-Aug-2019 10:17
    Excellent reminder. I guess in our search for such systems, we can slightly lose track of the meaning behind certain claims.

    ------------------------------
    Luis Limon
    Los Angeles CA
    United States
    ------------------------------



  • 7.  RE: QMS sofware and Clinical Study Management software solution for Med Device

    Posted 19-Aug-2019 07:49
    We use ensur, by DocXellent. They have both a cloud and server based system. It can control your documents and training, it also has a CAPA module, Incident Module (which can be used for complaints) and they do have something for audits (I have not looked into it yet), Supplier's can also be managed (again not looked into it yet). They also have a great form system that you can create your forms for your business (this is by far one of my favourite features). Thry don't as I know have an out of the box option for Clinical data management, however you may be able to make it work they using the forms and other tools. We bought this software in 2014 when we were about 35 employees, we are now about 85 and it has grown quite well with us. Let me know if you want further details or have other questions.

    ------------------------------
    Keri Froese RAC
    QA Manager
    Spartan Bioscience
    Ottawa
    Canada
    ------------------------------



  • 8.  RE: QMS sofware and Clinical Study Management software solution for Med Device

    This message was posted by a user wishing to remain anonymous
    Posted 19-Aug-2019 11:38
    This message was posted by a user wishing to remain anonymous

    MasterControl is the top end, nearly most expensive, on the market.  We are about the same size company as you and 6 figures a year for software licensing is out of our budget.  Just to implement 2 modules is $39K, then $19K per year after the first year.  Some others on the market that are in a lower price category but not just the basics....Greenlight Guru, Qualio,  QT9.


  • 9.  RE: QMS sofware and Clinical Study Management software solution for Med Device

    Posted 19-Aug-2019 14:21
    Edited by Tonia E. Bryant 19-Aug-2019 14:21
    Some software platforms are a bit clunky out of the box and require customization (Master Control being one of them). I too work for a very small company and we conducted demonstrations of multiple systems. We selected Greenlight Guru due to pricing and also for the fact that the software is medical device only. They implement the regulatory requirements into the software to help customers meet them (e.g. 21 CFR 820, ISO 13485:2016). Modules include document management, product development (design & risk management), audit, CAPA, customer feedback, and nonconforming product. Their intention is to release a training module this year.

    The group is extremely responsive to customer feedback and will work to implement customer feature requests.

    Lastly, when a major release occurs, Greenlight provides you with all of their validation documentation and templates for you to complete your own validations.

    If you want some contact information, please contact me privately.

    ------------------------------
    Tonia Bryant
    Director, Quality & Regulatory Affairs
    Cary NC
    United States
    ------------------------------



  • 10.  RE: QMS sofware and Clinical Study Management software solution for Med Device

    This message was posted by a user wishing to remain anonymous
    Posted 20-Aug-2019 08:50
    This message was posted by a user wishing to remain anonymous

    How about Trackwise as a QMS? Is that worth investing for QMS when compared with Veeva Vault Quality Docs? As per my experience, Sparta systems' QMS is pretty mature software in the life sciences industry but not sure about pricing aspects. Any thoughts?


  • 11.  RE: QMS sofware and Clinical Study Management software solution for Med Device

    Posted 20-Aug-2019 09:49
    I would highly recommend you begin first with an internal needs assessment and get feedback from not only IT, but all types of end users.  How many users will you have?  What features would you like (ideally)?  Do you have PC and Mac users?  Can the system allow for different levels of security (including external consultants) and is it fully audit trailed?  Do you have specific IT requirements (e.g. do you want a cloud based system)?  What is your budget and timeline for implementation? How often do product upgrades come out and how might this impact you?  What kinds of reports/dashboards would you like to generate and can you do this easily?  Then you can conduct a search, narrow down the field and invite companies to demo/bid.  All too often I have seen IT folks make purchasing decisions for clinical/regulatory without understanding their needs.  This usually results in low uptake/work-arounds, lost productivity and costly changes.

    ------------------------------
    Jennifer Kealy
    Head of Quality, Clinical and Regulatory Affairs
    FIND
    Genève
    Switzerland
    ------------------------------



  • 12.  RE: QMS sofware and Clinical Study Management software solution for Med Device

    Posted 21-Aug-2019 11:25
    Jennifer makes a great point.  Forget about getting any sort of recommendations here generally for stuff like this.  Your starting point, if you ask any reputable supplier, is really the "User Requirements" document or a detailed list of must haves, nice-to haves, options and an understanding of what you need to store, how the information come in (format, data sets, etc.) and then a good look at what you plan to do with the information in the system.  If this is meant solely as a "file cabinet" (or a file cabinet with some bells and whistles) then one type of system is going to be preferred just based on your requirements.  If you have reporting envisioned as a required functionality, then a different type of system will be called for simply based on this decision.  If you need something that can grow with your company by addition of modules or additional pieces then you are looking at a different set of options.

    Without the user requirements well understood and well defined, I hate to say it but, your project is already derailed.  If you simply plow headlong into buying a system (or even setting up appointments for demos) without knowing what you want, need, or desire, your headed for a potentially significant outlay of capital with high potential for not getting what you need, getting lots of things you don't need or want, or having a significant issue with user acceptance and user compliance without lots of time trying to figure out work arounds.​

    ------------------------------
    Victor Mencarelli
    Director Regulatory Affairs
    United States
    ------------------------------



  • 13.  RE: QMS sofware and Clinical Study Management software solution for Med Device

    Posted 21-Aug-2019 11:06
    Edited by Kamran Younis 21-Aug-2019 11:06
    Hi,
    Just building on others' recommendations.  Having looked at at least a dozen different systems, I would recommend that for a small company of your size, you either go with Qualio or Pilgrim.
    Try to stay away from full-blown Enterprise level eQMS as noted by others; you will spend a lot to "customize."


    ------------------------------
    Kamran Younis
    Mr
    Butler NJ
    United States
    ------------------------------